Black is a powerful and versatile color that has been used in art for centuries. Whether used to create depth and contrast in a painting or as the main focus of a piece, black has a unique ability to make a statement.
In the world of art pigments, there are several different types of black available, each with its own characteristics and properties.
In this article, we will explore two popular black pigments: lamp black and Mars black. We will compare their definitions, characteristics, pros, and cons to help you determine which one is right for your artistic needs.
Lamp Black
Lamp black is a type of black pigment that is made by collecting the soot produced when burning certain types of oils or resins.
It has been used as a pigment for centuries and was traditionally made by collecting the soot produced when burning these materials in a specially designed lamp.
Lamp black is known for its granulating and uneven texture, which can make it difficult to work with in some situations. It can be challenging to create a smooth, even application of the pigment, and it may not mix well with other colors.
However, some artists find that the granulating texture of lamp black can be used to their advantage, adding interest and texture to their paintings. Lamp black is also considered to be a very light-fast pigment, meaning it is resistant to fading over time.
Mars Black
Mars black is a synthetic black pigment made from iron oxide and other chemicals. It was first developed in the early 20th century and has become a popular alternative to traditional black pigments such as lamp black and bone black.
One of the main characteristics of Mars Black is its smooth, matte finish. It is much easier to work with than lamp black, as it can be easily mixed with other colors and applied smoothly to a surface. It is also considered to be a very light-fast pigment, meaning it is resistant to fading over time.
However, some artists find that Mars black can appear somewhat flat and lifeless in a painting, lacking the depth and interest of more granulating pigments. It may also have a slightly cool undertone, which can be noticeable when used alongside warm colors.
Pros and Cons of Lamp Black and Mars Black
Lamp Black and Mars Black are both black pigments commonly used in painting. Here are some pros and cons of each:
Lamp Black
Pros:
- Lamp Black is considered to be a very light-fast pigment, meaning it is resistant to fading over time.
- The granulating texture of Lamp Black can be used to add interest and texture to paintings, making it suitable for certain artistic styles.
- Lamp Black can be used to create different values of black by adding more or less water to the paint.
Cons:
- Lamp Black has a granulating and uneven texture, which can make it difficult to work with in some situations.
- It can be challenging to create a smooth, even application of the pigment, and it may not mix well with other colors.
- Lamp Black is not a very opaque pigment, so it may require several layers to achieve a solid black.
Mars Black:
Pros:
- Mars Black is a more opaque black pigment compared to Lamp Black, making it ideal for creating solid black areas in a painting.
- It has a smoother texture compared to Lamp Black, making it easier to work with and blend with other colors.
- Mars Black is versatile and can be used for a range of painting techniques, including watercolor, acrylic, and oil painting.
Cons:
- Mars Black is less lightfast compared to Lamp Black, meaning it may fade over time if not stored and displayed correctly.
- It is less granulating compared to Lamp Black, which may not be suitable for artists who want to create texture and interest in their paintings.
- Mars Black can be more expensive compared to Lamp Black.
Choosing between Lamp Black and Mars Black depends on the artist’s preference, style, and technique. Lamp Black may be suitable for artists who want to create texture and interest in their paintings.
While Mars Black may be more suitable for artists who want to create solid black areas. It is essential to consider the pros and cons of each pigment before selecting one for a particular project.
Comparison of Lamp Black and Mars Black
Texture
Lamp Black has a granulating and uneven texture, which can add interest and texture to a painting. Mars Black, on the other hand, has a smoother texture and produces a consistent, even application.
Opacity
Mars Black is more opaque compared to Lamp Black, making it ideal for creating solid black areas in a painting. Lamp Black, on the other hand, is less opaque and may require several layers to achieve a solid black.
Lightfastness
Lamp Black is considered to be a very light-fast pigment, meaning it is resistant to fading over time. Mars Black, however, is less lightfast compared to Lamp Black, meaning it may fade over time if not stored and displayed correctly.
Mixing
Lamp Black may not mix well with other colors due to its granulating texture, whereas Mars Black is easy to mix with other colors and produces a consistent result.
Price
Mars Black can be more expensive compared to Lamp Black.
Personal Preference
Ultimately, the choice between Lamp Black and Mars Black will depend on the individual artist and their desired effect. Some artists may prefer Lamp Black for its texture, while others may prefer Mars Black for its consistency.
Comparison of Lamp Black and Mars Black Pigments
| Black Pigment | Definition | Characteristics | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lamp Black | Traditional pigment made from soot | Granulating, uneven texture | Adds depth and texture to paintings | Difficult to work with, may not mix well with other colors |
| Mars Black | Synthetic pigment made from iron oxide and other chemicals | Smooth, matte finish | Easy to work with, produces consistent, even application | May appear flat and lifeless, may have cool undertone |
FAQs
Yes, black pigments can be mixed with other colors to create different shades and tones. For example, adding a small amount of black to a red pigment will create a deeper, more muted version of red.
Yes, it is possible to create a black pigment by mixing other colors together. This is often done by mixing complementary colors, such as blue and orange or red and green. It is also possible to create a black by mixing a variety of colors together in equal proportions.
Yes, different black pigments can have different properties, such as granulating texture, lightfastness, and color tone. It is important to consider these properties when choosing a black pigment for a particular project.
Yes, black pigments can be used in watercolor paintings. However, some artists may prefer to mix their own blacks and darks using various pigments, rather than using pre-mixed tube blacks.
This is a common statement in art education, but it is not entirely true. While black may not be a common color in nature, it does appear in various forms such as mineral deposits, seeds, insects, and sand. The statement is often used to encourage artists to mix their own blacks and darks using various pigments, rather than relying on pre-mixed tube blacks.
Conclusion
Both lamp black and Mars black are valuable black pigments that can be used in a variety of artistic applications.
Lamp black is a traditional pigment made from soot and is known for its granulating and uneven texture, while Mars black is a synthetic pigment with a smooth, matte finish.
While both pigments have their pros and cons, the choice between them will depend on the individual artist and their desired effect.
Some artists may prefer the depth and texture of lamp black, while others may find the smooth finish of Mars black more suitable for their style.
It is important to keep in mind that there are no hard and fast rules in art, and different techniques and approaches work for different people.
The best way to determine which black pigment is right for you is to experiment with both and see what works best for your style and technique.
Leave a Reply